{{status_msg}}

Home Prices Are Softening. What Buyers Can Negotiate Now

Posted:

November 17th

  • Share on Facebook

For over three years, American homes consistently sold for prices higher than those a year prior. However, this trend has finally broken. Data from October indicates that the median home sale price has dipped slightly below that of the previous year, marking the first annual decrease since the spring of 2023. Concurrently, the inventory of homes for sale has reached its highest point since early 2020, pending sales have fallen to the lowest levels seen in over a decade (excluding the early pandemic), and roughly 20% of listings have seen a price reduction.

Unfortunately, the cost of borrowing has risen again. Recently, the average rate for a 30-year fixed mortgage has surged back into the mid-7% range after a brief period of improvement. While buyers have more room to negotiate, many households still find monthly payments challenging.

This scenario presents a unique opportunity. With fewer offers and extended market durations for homes, sellers are more open to negotiation. Prices and terms are increasingly seen as starting points rather than fixed numbers. If you're on the hunt for a home this winter, here are some negotiation points to consider and how to work effectively with your agent and lender.

Understanding a slight dip in prices

A national decrease of less than half a percent isn't indicative of a crisis, nor does it mean prices are plummeting everywhere. Some high-end coastal areas with limited inventory are still experiencing robust growth, while several major metropolitan areas in the South and West have reported price declines of several percentage points over the past year. Your specific local market will largely dictate the trends affecting you.

The national figures indicate a realignment of power dynamics. When homes take longer to sell and listings face decreased buyer interest, sellers tend to exhibit greater flexibility in negotiations. This openness can affect both pricing and the overall terms of the sale.

Price is just one aspect of negotiation

Many buyers tend to concentrate solely on the purchase price, but in this high-rate environment, monthly payments and the amount required at closing can be even more significant. Reducing the price by a few thousand dollars has a minimal impact on your mortgage, while reallocating that same amount elsewhere might provide greater financial relief. You might consider negotiating the following in a softer market:

  • A price lower than the listed amount
  • A seller concession to cover closing costs
  • Completion of repairs ahead of closing or a credit instead
  • Seller-funded support to lower your mortgage rate
  • A closing date or timeline that accommodates your plans
  • Inclusion of items like appliances or window coverings in the home sale

Your agent has insights into how sellers in the local market are responding and can assist you in determining which elements to emphasize in your offer. The focus should be on securing the most impactful concessions rather than trying to obtain everything possible.

Reducing the cash burden with closing cost credits

Closing expenses typically constitute several percentage points of the loan sum, in addition to your down payment. Many first-time buyers find that gathering these funds can be a significant hurdle in the home buying process. A seller's credit can help with these costs directly, reducing the amount you need to bring to the closing table.

However, there are restrictions. Different loan programs may limit how much a seller can contribute, often ranging from 3% to 9% of the sale price, depending on the loan type and size of your down payment, and a credit can usually not exceed your actual closing costs. It's best to consult with your lender early on about what your loan permits to ensure your offer aligns with these guidelines.

Understanding how a rate buydown works

With mortgage rates now above 7%, a valuable offer from a seller could be assistance with lowering your interest rate. There are generally two main strategies for this.

A permanent buydown requires discount points paid at closing to cut your interest rate for the entire duration of the loan. Each point costs 1% of the total loan amount, and the rate reduction varies by lender and market conditions. If you're planning to hold onto the loan for a long time, this option could be beneficial.

Alternatively, a temporary buydown reduces your payments for the first couple of years. Typically, one common structure sees the rate drop by two percentage points in the first year and one percentage point in the second year, before reverting to the full rate. For instance, on a $350,000 mortgage at around 7.34%, the monthly payment would be approximately $2,409. With a temporary buydown, the initial year's payment could be about $1,952, and the second-year payment around $2,176, before it increases to the full amount in year three. Such an arrangement might cost just over $8,000, which a seller may prefer to fund rather than reducing the sale price by the same amount.

This temporary buydown isn't a long-term solution, you need to be comfortable with the full payment once the discount expires, and lenders generally qualify you based on the complete rate. If interest rates decline in the future, refinancing could be a path to consider, but there's no guarantee of when or if that will happen.

Inspection remains crucial

In a previous frantic market, it was common for buyers to waive inspections or greatly limit their requests to secure a deal. In today's slower climate, the pressure to forgo these protections has diminished. Conducting a thorough home inspection provides essential insights about the condition of the property's roof, HVAC systems, plumbing, electrical systems, and foundation before you make a commitment.

If the inspection reveals any issues, your agent can guide you in determining whether to seek repairs, a reduction in price, or a credit. Opting for credits can simplify the process compared to having a seller handle repairs, giving you control over who performs the work and how it is done, though the best choice will depend on the specifics of the issue and your loan requirements.

Prepare your financing in advance

Having negotiating power won't be valuable if your finance isn't solid. A seller evaluating multiple offers typically favors the buyer who appears most capable of closing. Thus, before you start serious searches, obtain a complete preapproval rather than a simple prequalification, establish your comfortable monthly payment rather than merely your maximum loan amount, and compare offers from multiple lenders. Also, inquire with each lender about how they would manage a seller concession or rate buydown to avoid unexpected complications later.

Key questions to discuss with your agent

  • How long are homes in this area lasting on the market, and how many are seeing price cuts?
  • Would a price decrease, a concession for closing costs, or a rate buydown be most advantageous for my budget?
  • What factors regarding this particular home's state and history might influence my requests?
  • What contingencies should I maintain in my offer to protect my interests?

The takeaway

A declining market doesn't equate to cheap buying, especially with rising mortgage rates. However, it does grant prepared buyers more latitude in structuring a deal that aligns with their financial situation. With robust financing in place and a clear understanding of your priorities, along with the support of your agent and lender, you may secure terms that were once unimaginable for buyers just a year or two ago.

Rewritten using AI

Send Us a Message